Atmosphere Harvesting

Much of the mass that needs to be lifted into orbit consists of propulsion fluids, and the the majority of the fluid is the oxidizer. The total cost of operating in space could be reduced if there was a ready supply of liquid oxygen already in orbit. One application would be to refuel space tugs. The idea is that instead of blasting oxygen into space using rockets, gradually gather oxygen by skimming the extreme upper atmosphere. This idea goes back to work by Serge T. Demetriades, and it was published in the Journal of the British Interplanetary Society (Serge T. Demetriades, “A Novel System for Space Flight Using a Propulsive Fluid Accumulator”, J. British Interplanetary Society, 17 (1959) pp. 114-119.). The original idea was to gather gas, liquefy, and separate the oxygen from nitrogen. The nitrogen could then be used as a propulsive reaction mass using an MHD device. There are some nice cartoons of the device here. The whole thing would be powered by a nuclear reactor. Solar power would be impractical because of the added drag of the panels. A space tug would periodically dock with the device to transfer the liquid oxygen.The concept has come to known by the name PROFAC.

The concept has been reworked more recently by a team at Worcester Polytechnic Institute. From what I can gather, Paul Klinkman began reconsider PROFAC in about 2005. In particular, he found it beneficial to raise the collection altitude to 150-200 km where there is a higher concentration of oxygen, and he has proposed methods for collection. The most complete technical reference I’ve been able to find is an internal document by a WPI undergraduate. There’s also some information in this report, but the report focuses mostly on team dynamics. There is also AIAA Paper 2009-6759, but I have been motivated to purchase a copy. What originally intrigued me about the WPI work is the idea of using an electrodynamic tether for propulsion. This a particularly good application for tether propulsion because the system stays near the earth where the earth’s magnetic field is strong. And a long cable could raise solar panels far enough above the atmosphere to reduce the total drag. But mostly I liked the idea because I have a bunch of notes from 1983 that explore this combination of tethers and PROFAC (no claim of precedence; only publishing counts, and I didn’t publish anything, plus I don’t care). It appears that Klinkman has now moved away from tethers as the preferred propulsion for PROFAC, but I’d like continue to do some studies. As an aside, everyone assumes that nitrogen is a byproduct, but I think that any mass at orbital velocity is valuable in an integrated space transportation system. Below is my cartoon of what the system might look like.

Sketch of tether powered PROFAC

Mass accumulator with electrodynamic tether propulsion

The most recent website update is a page on atmosphere harvesting, and the one study included to date is a solution for the shape a tether takes when used to drag a collector through the atmosphere. I was curious about the relation between the tidal forces that tend to keep the tether vertical and the drag at one end that will tend to bend the tether horizontally. The equations come from my 1983 notes, but at the time I didn’t have a handy way to solve the resulting coupled differential equations. The current Mathematica NDSolve function has no problem at all. There’s some heavy calculus involved, so I don’t particularly recommend the study as casual reading unless you need to do a similar calculation. I plan to use the results in a more complete system study, which should make for more interesting reading.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>